It already has been dubbed by the media – Cablegate. I hate this name with a passion, and will not be using it. I’m sorry news media, but Watergate happened in the 70s, and was the name of a hotel. This does not give you free licence to add -gate to the end of any event that embarrasses the US government. (Correction: I have been informed it was Wikileaks who dubbed the release as such, not the media. This does not make me hate it’s use any less, however.)
Here’s what happened. A website called Wikileaks, well known for leaking information that shows corruption in government and generally takes a stance against all material deemed ‘Classified’ without a damn good reason, have released 251,287 US diplomatic ‘cables’. As far as I can tell, these cables are (or rather were) secure communications between members of the US Govt, mainly to and from diplomats. Also released were 8000 State Department ‘directives’, which in my mind more or less equate to marching orders. About half of the material was unclassified, with only 6% being marked ‘secret’. Some of them are embarrasing, not only to the US but to other nations as well. The information was released to 5 major media outlets, and unlike most of their previous leaks is not available on their website (yet). However The Guardian has released the information to date en masse and apparently verbatim, and can be found here.
What we have so far is the tip of the iceberg – it appears that Wikileaks are releasing the information over a period of a week, essentially drip feeding it to the greedy maws of the selected media outlets. Given what we have seen so far, I am eager to see the rest – I will do an update of this post later this week when some more of the new material is out.
There are many revelations, most of which I don’t care about, but here are a few that I found interesting;
-King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia has actively and repeatedly urged the US to attack Iran and destroy their nuclear weapons programme, apparently quoted as saying that they must ‘cut off the head of the snake’ before it is too late.
-Since 2007, the US have tried and failed to remove nuclear material from research facilities in Pakistan out of fear the material might make its way into the hands of terrorists. Keep in mind that the US and Pakistan are supposedly allies.
-Private Saudi donors are the primary source of Al Qaeda’s money, as well as other terrorist groups. Interesting that they seem to be following the money, but aren’t able to find the source, or remove it if they have.
-Foreign nations such as Slovenia and Kiribati were ‘highly incentivized’ – basically bribed – into taking Guantanamo Bay prisoners after that site came under scrutiny. Bribing other countries so they you can continue to torture prisoners – bloody good show USA, bloody good show.
-The attack on Google not so long ago was at the direction of China’s government (this was long suspected, but apparently this is proof). China has also broken into US government computers as well as the Dalai Lama’s computer and a multitude of American businesses since at least 2002.
And that is just one day. There is still the better part of a week to go, and this just stands to get better and better from a gleeful US-bashing perspective. And while I do love a good US bashing, I am actually not sure what my opinion of these leaks are.
This isn’t a whistle-blowing incident. There is very little corruption shows in these files. Theres not much wrongdoing at all. It is the governmental equivalent of hacking someones email account and posting all of their private opinions on an open forum. Julian Assange (founder of Wikileaks) has been quoted as saying that the cables show the “US spying on its allies and the UN; turning a blind eye to corruption and human rights abuse in ‘client states’, which is perfectly true – but is anyone really surprised? Most nation spy on most other nations – this is just a fact of the world. And we have already had Guantanamo Bay to prove the latter (though having details to continue that particular debacle is interesting). Was it really necessary to release all of this information?
On the whole, I find myself agreeing with the release. It does highlight to the public in general exactly what the US has been up to. Who knows, maybe it will lead to real change among US leadership (yeah, right). The depth of treachery that a few of the missives show is nessecary to put out in the public domain. But I take issue with all the rest, the material that was released merely because they could. Going back to the email analogy, it is like uploading a zip of the entire contents of the email account, rather than just posting the juicy embarrasing bits. It is overkill, and not in a good way – it strikes me with malice.
On the whole, Wikileaks is still doing the right thing in my opinion, but let me say that I am beginning to doubt their true motives.